How to Start Selling Pokémon Cards on Whatnot

How to Start Selling Pokémon Cards on Whatnot
Table of Contents

The Pokémon card market is hotter than ever, with collectors and investors constantly searching for rare and valuable cards. Whatnot has emerged as one of the best platforms for selling Pokémon cards through live auctions, offering sellers a dynamic and engaging way to connect with buyers. If you want to turn your Pokémon card collection into profit, this guide will walk you through everything you need to know to start selling on Whatnot

Why Sell Pokémon Cards on Whatnot?

Whatnot provides a unique selling experience that combines live auctions, real-time interaction, and instant transactions. Unlike traditional marketplaces like eBay or TCGPlayer, Whatnot allows sellers to showcase their inventory in a live format, building excitement and competition among buyers. Here are a few reasons to consider selling on Whatnot:

  • Real-Time Engagement: You can interact with buyers directly, answer questions, and showcase products in real-time.
  • Faster Sales: Unlike fixed-price marketplaces, auctions create urgency, leading to quicker sales. 
  • Building a Community: Engaging with customers during live streams can help create a loyal customer base.
  • Convenience: Whatnot handles payment processing and provides a shipping label, simplifying the logistics of selling.

Tips to Start Selling Pokémon Cards on Whatnot

Now that you understand why Whatnot is a great platform, let’s go over the steps to successfully sell Pokémon cards.

1. Sign up and Get Approved as a Seller

Before selling on Whatnot, you need to apply for a seller account. Here’s how:

  • Download the Whatnot app: It’s available on iOS and Android, or you can visit the Whatnot website.
  • Apply for Seller Approval: Since Whatnot vets all sellers to maintain quality, you need to fill out an application. Provide details about your experience selling collectibles and include photos of your inventory. 
  • Wait for Approval: Depending on demand, getting approval as a seller can take a few days to a few weeks. 

Tips to Get Approved Faster:

  • Provide clear and professional photos of your Pokémon cards.
  • Share links to other platforms where you’ve sold items (e.g., eBay, TCGPlayer, Instagram).
  • Highlight your knowledge of Pokémon cards and live selling experience if applicable.

2. Source Your Pokémon Card Inventory

To be a successful seller, you need a good inventory. Here’s how to build a solid collection:

Where to Buy Pokémon Cards for Resale:

  • Personal Collection: Start with cards you already own.
  • Local Card Shops: Many shops offer bulk deals on common and uncommon cards.
  • eBay or TCGPlayer: Purchase cards at competitive prices and resell them for a profit.
  • Facebook Marketplace & Craigslist: Look for local deals on collections.
  • Retail Stores: Buy sealed Pokémon products like booster packs and Elite Trainer Boxes for live breaks.

What Types of Cards Sell Best?

  • Vintage Cards: Cards from Base Set, Jungle, Fossil, and early sets are in high demand.
  • Holo & Reverse Holo Cards: Collectors love shiny cards from all eras.
  • Full Art & Secret Rares: Modern sets have valuable and stunning full art cards.
  • Popular Pokémon: Pikachu, Charizard, and Eevee evolutions tend to sell quickly.
  • Graded Cards: PSA, GBS, and CGC graded cards usually sell for higher prices.

3. Organize and Protect Your Inventory

Organize and Protect Your Inventory

Having an organized inventory makes selling Pokémon cards much more manageable. Here’s how to keep things in order.

  • Sort by Set and Rarity: Separate your cards by Pokémon set, rarity, and condition.
  • Use Protective Sleeves: Store cards in penny sleeves, top loaders, or binders to prevent damage.
  • Create an Inventory List: Use a spreadsheet to track what you have, prices, and estimated values.

4. Setting Up Your Whatnot Profile

Before going live, you need a polished Whatnot profile.

Key Elements of a Strong Profile:

  • Profile Picture: Use a clear image or logo.
  • Username: Choose a catchy, easy-to-remember name.
  • Bio: Briefly describe what you sell (e.g., “Live Pokémon card auctions every Friday”)
  • Social Links: Connect your Instagram, X, or YouTube accounts to drive traffic.

5. Prepare for Your First Live Auction

Choose the Right Setup:

  • Camera and Lighting: A well-lit space ensures your cards look great on camera. Use a tripod or phone stand for stability. 
  • Background: Keep it clean and Pokémon-themed as possible.
  • Audio: A clear microphone ensures viewers hear you well.

Auction Strategy: 

  • Start with Low Bids: Low starting prices encourage bidding wars,
  • Group Similar Cards: Selling cards in groups (e.g., 10 holos for $5) can move inventory faster.
  • Highlight Key Cards: Show off rare or valuable cards to attract buyers.

6. Go Live and Sell Your Pokémon Cards

Go Live and Sell Your Pokémon Cards

When you go live, engagement is key. Here’s how to keep viewers interested:

  • Greet Viewers: A warm welcome makes people feel included.
  • Show Cards Clearly: Move slowly so buyers can see details.
  • Answer Questions: Engage with viewers by responding to chat messages.
  • Keep the Energy Up: A fun and exciting stream keeps people watching and bidding.

7. Use Giveaways to Attract Viewers

Giveaways are a powerful way to increase engagement. Offer a free pack or card to random viewers who participate in the chat or follow you. Announce giveaways in advance to encourage more attendees to your live show.

8. Manage Shipping Efficiently

It’s also important to efficiently ship your cards to buyers. Luckily, Whatnot provides shipping labels, making it easy to fulfill orders. 

Shipping Tips: 

  • Package Securely: Use bubble mailers and top loaders to protect cards.
  • Ship Promptly Buyers appreciate fast shipping, so make sure you are shipping the cards out on time.
  • Track Shipments: Use Whatnot’s tracking system to make sure the cards are delivered.

9. Promote Your Stream on Social Media

Driving external traffic to your Whatnot streams can boost sales. 

Where to Promote:

  • Instagram: Post story updates with countdowns.
  • TikTok: Make short videos showcasing your best cards.
  • X: Post when you’re going live.
  • YouTube: Upload past Whatnot streams for additional exposure.

10. Learn and Improve Over Time

The best Whatnot sellers constantly refine their strategy. Pay attention to:

  • What Sells Best: Track which cards get the most bids.
  • Best Streaming Times: Find when your audience is most active.
  • Viewer Feedback: Ask for suggestions to improve your streams.

Get Started Selling Pokémon Cards on Whatnot

Selling Pokémon cards on Whatnot is an exciting way to turn your passion into a business. You can build a loyal following and generate consistent sales by sourcing quality inventory, engaging with buyers, and optimizing your auctions. If you’re getting started, don’t be discouraged if your first few streams aren’t as packed with users. Keep improving, and success will come with time.

Want to take your reselling game to the next level? Subscribe to the Resale Pro newsletter! You’ll get expert insights, the latest reselling strategies, and exclusive tips straight to your inbox. Whether you’re flipping Pokémon cards, sneakers, or electronics, Resale Pro keeps you ahead of the competition. Sign up today and start maximizing your profits!

Picture of ReSalePro
ReSalePro
Meet Resale Pro, the go-to resource for resellers, providing essential tips and insights to help you thrive and create a successful online reselling business.  
Picture of ReSalePro
ReSalePro
Meet Resale Pro, the go-to resource for resellers, providing essential tips and insights to help you thrive and create a successful online reselling business.  

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Subscribe to unlock secrets to success: tips, guides,
and insights delivered to your inbox.

Recent Posts

Related Articles

Sign Up for Our Newsletter

Subscribe to unlock secrets to success: tips, guides, and insights delivered to your inbox.